How much AI is too much AI? - or - Why does the industry enjoy drinking the bongwater?
Lately I've seen discussion go around in a server I'm in (again), regarding the controversy with House House's use of AI and obfuscation of said use in the creation of their newest game, Big Walk. The main issue I had is it revealed to me the fact that some people don't really hate AI entirely, they just dislike the consequences.
AI? In my Big Walk?
For those who came in late, here's the skinny (at least as I understand it): Near the end of the initial development phase of Big Walk, House House encountered an issue with Unity (the game engine Big Walk is made in) rendering shadows for objects that were outside the few of the camera (and thus should have been culled). When they went to Unity's in-house engineers for a fix... they said it was impossible to fix.
PEOPLE PAY FOR THIS SUPPORT BY THE WAY
So, under the impression that there was no other way to find a solution, the folks at House House decided that, like Adam and Eve eating from the forbidden fruit, they would allow themselves to be tainted in order to gain higher understanding...
Or, in layman's terms, they asked an LLM to write code to make the shadows go away when the object isn't in view.
Wut? U angry?
Now obviously, people were super angry about this. However the way we found out only added to the fire.
When the game came out on Steam (and such is the case as of writing this article), the game DID NOT have the AI Generated Content disclosure at the bottom of the page. So obviously consumers assumed that the game was free of any and all tainted code when the game came out, House House were longtime, notable developers in the industry, they WOULD NEVER dare use AI.
Around a month or two ago a game related awards event - the Golden Joystick Awards if i recall - came about, as part of nomination, developers were required to disclose any and ALL AI usage. House House admitted, they had used AI to write that last teeny bit of code before the game's launch.
Overnight, the internet exploded like a match on gasoline, and why shouldn't they have?
How not to be honest in a dishonest industry.
Now, don't get me wrong, I think AI has no place in any form of artistic expression, and that includes video games. But I'm not gonna shoot someone to death over 10 lines of code in a game as ambitious as Big Walk seems to be.
However, I'm rather upset, quite angry even. The thing about Steam's AI disclosure is it isn't just so people can go "eugh" and walk away, it also pushes game developers to be honest with their consumers. When an established developer puts out a game, people don't just buy it because it looks good, but because the company has proven to release honest and good products that were worth buying. Trust is important in basically any consumer industry.
So of course, when we learned of the AI usage in Big Walk, the internet went FERAL, and I cannot say I blame them. House House not only destroyed long-term trust by using AI, but they destroyed past AND future trust by hiding the usage of AI from consumers. They never once bothered to be transparent about an otherwise minimal use of AI in a large game.
"Artificial? NEVER!"
In closing, do I think the reaction people had to this whole shebang is extreme? Yes! Do I think it's unreasonable? NO! People are right to be upset, they paid for a game they assumed was AI free and were met with a surprise, a surprise only revealed because the developers were forced to be transparent about the use of AI.
I think AI should not be allowed to program, the idea that people let AI do things for them, think for them, be ""creative"" for them. It's not even as gross as it is dystopian. Programming and game development is art, AI cannot make art. The only thing I can see AI having genuine merit for in programming is reverse-engineering data formats, but even then that's been kinda ruined with all the "claude, jork it a little and then put Mario in Dark Souls" type shit.
I've seen people advocate for AI coding, even if it's just a small amount, and yet they show disdain for AI images or music. If we don't want AI in our art, we should keep it out of ALL KINDS of art, even if you don't understand it.
To support me and help me write more articles like this, support me on ko-fi at https://ko-fi.com/bloxxel64colonthree
Thank you and good night.